10 Comments
User's avatar
Jen Screamer's avatar

I'm afraid we've found ourselves in a perfect storm where Huxley is both right and wrong.

Expand full comment
Richard Aston's avatar

Huxley both right and wrong... How so?

Expand full comment
Cate Salenger's avatar

Well, Huxley certainly writes like an Eton professor. I wonder what these guys would think of the state of the world now. I see that Huxley was writing from Wrightwood, CA. If that's the same town in the San Bernardino mountains that I know of, I can't imagine how he'd end up there. There's not too much now, and probably great solitude in 1949.

Expand full comment
Old Owl's avatar

The Orwell-Huxley argument shown graphically:

https://www.highexistence.com/amusing-ourselves-to-death-huxley-vs-orwell/

Expand full comment
Parker McCoy's avatar

I definitely enjoy both books, with a slight preference toward 1984. Huxley may very well be right, though. The powers that be definitely will use sex and the conditioning of little kids for the purposes of shaping their minds and therefore, society of course. Great post, though. That's awesome that the letter is still around.

Expand full comment
Blue Fairy Wren's avatar

I always thought Huxley's novel to be superior in both the quality of the writing and the concept. However, we now find ourselves living in a world where both have come true simultaneously. Governments have manufactured consent to an absurd level and now the "boot on the face" has been added as good measure. Bleak times, indeed.

Expand full comment
SJStone's avatar

As I continue to write my political satire, Gulliver's Travels: The Broligarchy, I'm often thinking of both Huxley and Orwell, while staring ashamed and horrified at what is happening in America today. I'm please to participate in any number of protests, sit-ins and strikes, but as an author myself, I find that writing about this is one of the best ways to put my talents to good use.

https://readingwritingrevolution.substack.com/s/gullivers-travels

Expand full comment
Richard Aston's avatar

And... What do you make of Huxley's position?

Expand full comment
SJStone's avatar

I think Huxley had a lot of it correct -- bread and circuses. Americans -- and as an American, I will totally put a foot in our collective asses -- have been out to lunch for the better part of the last 25 years, simply missing out on everything that's led to this point. We got comfortable, and everyone forgot that democracy is a participation sport. As consumers, we outsourced our civic responsibilities to the professional political class and sought leisure. We focused inward, building our families and recreating our homes with endless trips to Home Depot, all while ignoring the consolidation of power by the wealthy. And now, we're shifting towards Orwell, having been lulled into a false sense of oblivion. The question is whether or not we're willing to stand up now and stop it.

Expand full comment
Jim Geschke's avatar

I wrote a comparison of the two novels a few months back. If you're interested ...

https://jimgeschke.substack.com/p/orwell-vs-huxley

Expand full comment